top of page

Context #09 | Why are so many buildings still awaiting refurbishment?

Segmento Urbano
Nov 5
4 min read

With tax incentives and penalties in place, and barriers to adapting existing buildings, what determines whether urban rehabilitation policies work?



Urban rehabilitation has been a priority of Portugal’s spatial development policies for several years. Repairing deteriorating buildings, bringing existing properties back into use and revitalising urban centres are widely recognised objectives. Yet the continued presence of vacant or deteriorating buildings raises questions about how effective the available policy tools are in bringing about change.

Two recent municipal decisions have brought this issue back into focus.

On 28 October, Lisbon City Council approved a proposal to redraw the boundaries of its Urban Rehabilitation Area (ARU). The proposed area covers approximately 6,450 hectares, extending the area in which properties may qualify for certain tax benefits linked to rehabilitation. The proposal still requires approval from the Municipal Assembly.

In Porto, the municipal executive announced its intention to propose a tenfold increase in the standard rate of Municipal Property Tax (IMI) for vacant properties in the historic centre in 2027. The aim is to encourage owners to bring those properties back into use or onto the market.

The two initiatives use different policy tools to encourage more active use of existing buildings.

Both raise a fundamental question. If there are incentives to refurbish buildings and penalties for keeping them vacant, why do so many buildings remain unused?



What prevents refurbishment?


Buildings can remain vacant for reasons other than a deliberate decision to keep them unoccupied.

Some owners may hold on to a property in anticipation of an increase in its value. In other cases, financial, technical, planning or legal difficulties may prevent work from going ahead.

Refurbishment costs, building defects, heritage constraints, regulatory requirements and difficulties securing finance can all affect whether a project is viable. Other obstacles include unresolved inheritance, disputes between co-owners and breaches of planning regulations.

It is therefore important to distinguish between properties that remain vacant despite being suitable for reuse and those where specific obstacles must be resolved before refurbishment can proceed.

Vacancy alone tells us little about whether a building can be refurbished straight away.

Owners still have a responsibility for their properties. Understanding why a building remains vacant helps determine what kind of public intervention is likely to work.



Can incentives or penalties solve the problem?


Tax benefits aim to improve the financial viability of refurbishment projects and make investment more attractive. Designating an Urban Rehabilitation Area can help, although individual projects still need to be brought forward and eligibility may vary from one property to another.

Higher taxes can also encourage owners who deliberately keep properties vacant to bring them back into use. Where vacancy stems from technical, legal or financial barriers, those barriers may persist even as the cost of holding the property rises.

The condition of a building and whether it is occupied are also distinct issues. A vacant building may need very little work before it can be used again, while a building in poor condition may still be occupied.

These differences matter when defining what each measure is intended to achieve and deciding where to apply it.

The question is when and how each policy tool can help bring about the intended change.



From assessment to action


Different barriers to refurbishment call for different public responses.

A first step is to build a clearer picture of vacant and deteriorating properties by combining occupancy records with information on their condition, the planning rules and constraints that apply, and any known barriers to intervention.

Municipalities already hold information from planning applications, spatial planning instruments and other administrative records. Bringing these datasets together and supplementing them with surveys and technical assessments where needed can help municipalities identify priorities and make better-informed decisions.

That assessment allows municipalities to select measures suited to each situation.

Where a property can readily be used but the owner chooses to keep it vacant, higher taxes may encourage them to bring it back into use. Where the main barrier is financial, tax benefits or access to funding may be more effective. Where planning or administrative obstacles stand in the way, the priority may be to clarify what work is permitted and improve the relevant procedures while upholding legal requirements.

Municipalities can begin with the tools they already have, bringing together existing information and identifying the obstacles they are in a position to address.

They should also assess the results. How many properties are brought back into use? How many are refurbished? Which barriers persist?

The test is whether these measures are bringing about the changes they were introduced to achieve.



Segmento Urbano’s perspective


The extent of an area covered by tax benefits and the level of the penalties tell us only part of what we need to know about the effectiveness of an urban rehabilitation policy. Its success depends on what changes are achieved and how they contribute to the objectives set for each area.

Achieving those results means combining knowledge of local conditions with economic tools and the capacity to act. In some cases, reducing costs may be enough to make a project financially viable. In others, the priority may be to resolve administrative difficulties, clarify the planning rules or make it easier to bring properties back into use.

Tailoring the response to each case may be possible through more targeted use of existing tools and procedures.

Urban rehabilitation also has a purpose beyond the physical repair of buildings. A refurbished property can increase the supply of housing, accommodate new economic activity or improve the quality of the urban environment. These outcomes also depend on the uses encouraged, who can access the space and how well the project responds to local needs.


Refurbishing existing buildings should therefore form part of a broader urban strategy that creates the conditions for them to play a role in the life of the city again.

SU-02 - JUSTIFICADO DIREITA.png

Porto

Lisbon​

Luanda

Praça de D. João I 80

4000-065 Porto, Portugal

​​Av. Dom João II 50, Edifício Mar Vermelho, Parque das Nações

1990-095 Lisboa, Portugal

Rua Rainha Ginga 37 2º Direito

Luanda, Angola

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • X
  • LinkedIn

© 2026. Segmento Urbano. All Rights Reserved

BARRA_LOGOS-02.png

Receive context, not just news.


We share insights, perspectives and projects that help frame decisions about territory. No noise, only when it matters.

bottom of page